Review Guidelines
Metta: Jurnal Ilmu Multidisiplin is committed to maintaining high academic standards through a rigorous, objective, transparent, and ethical peer-review process. The journal implements a single-blind peer-review system, in which reviewers are aware of the authors' identities, while reviewers' identities remain confidential. Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening are evaluated by at least one independent reviewer with relevant academic expertise.
The journal primarily publishes Original Research Articles and Review Articles. In addition, Case Studies and Literary Studies may be considered on a limited and selective basis, provided that they demonstrate substantial scholarly contributions, methodological rigor, analytical originality, and clear relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.
All four manuscript types may address research subjects within the humanities, social sciences, management, or interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary fields connecting these areas.
1. Initial Manuscript Review
Reviewers should initially examine the manuscript's title, abstract, and overall content to determine its relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.
The journal encompasses three principal disciplinary areas:
1) Humanities: Arts, history, languages, literature, music, philosophy, religion, theater, cultural studies, and other related humanities disciplines.
2) Social Sciences: Geography, sociology, education, political science, law, public policy, social studies, history, philosophy, anthropology, and other related social science disciplines.
3) Management: Commerce, economics, finance, accounting, corporate governance, human resource management, marketing management, quality management, training and development, and other related management disciplines.
Interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary research integrating perspectives from these fields is also considered, provided that the manuscript demonstrates clear disciplinary relevance and substantial scholarly contributions.
The initial assessment should consider the manuscript's originality, academic significance, research objectives, methodological appropriateness, analytical quality, and potential contribution to theoretical development, empirical understanding, or practical applications within the relevant disciplinary field.
Reviewers must also assess whether the manuscript corresponds to one of the four accepted manuscript types:
a. Original Research Articles: Manuscripts presenting original empirical findings, theoretical investigations, or systematic scholarly analyses that contribute to the advancement of disciplinary or multidisciplinary knowledge.
b. Review Articles: Manuscripts providing critical, comprehensive, and methodologically sound examinations of existing scholarly literature, including original synthesis, identification of research gaps, and meaningful theoretical or empirical contributions.
c. Case Studies: Manuscripts presenting systematic and in-depth investigations of specific phenomena, institutions, organizations, communities, policies, events, or practices. These manuscripts are considered on a limited and selective basis and must demonstrate analytical originality, methodological rigor, and substantial scholarly significance.
d. Literary Studies: Manuscripts presenting original scholarly analyses of literary texts, historical documents, philosophical works, religious literature, cultural materials, organizational narratives, or other relevant textual sources. These manuscripts are considered on a limited and selective basis and must demonstrate theoretical relevance, interpretative rigor, and substantial scholarly contributions.
Reviewers should ensure that the manuscript complies with the journal's Author Guidelines, formatting requirements, and publication ethics standards.
Reviewers who lack sufficient disciplinary expertise, identify potential conflicts of interest, or cannot complete the evaluation within the specified timeframe must promptly inform the editorial team.
2. Comprehensive Manuscript Evaluation
Reviewers should conduct a thorough, systematic, and objective assessment of the manuscript based on the following criteria:
1. Originality and Scholarly Contribution: The manuscript presents original findings, theoretical arguments, conceptual insights, critical interpretations, or scholarly synthesis that meaningfully contributes to existing knowledge within the humanities, social sciences, management, or relevant multidisciplinary fields. The study must identify a significant research problem and demonstrate contributions beyond descriptive accounts or summaries of existing literature.
2. Title, Abstract, and Keywords: The title accurately represents the principal research subject, problem, or scholarly investigation and does not exceed 20 words. The abstract is presented in a single paragraph of no more than 250 words and clearly communicates the research background, objectives, methods, principal findings, and conclusions, with greater emphasis on the findings and conclusions. Keywords consist of three to five relevant terms that accurately represent the research subject, disciplinary context, or analytical perspectives.
3. Introduction: The introduction clearly establishes the research background, identifies relevant theoretical or empirical gaps, explains the significance of the study, and presents well-defined research objectives supported by appropriate scholarly literature. The discussion must establish the relationship between the investigated problem, previous research, identified research gaps, and the manuscript's expected scholarly contribution.
4. Research Methodology: The methodology is appropriate to the research objectives, disciplinary context, and selected research approach. The Method section must clearly and operationally describe the research type, design, participants or data sources where applicable, sampling or source selection procedures, instruments, data collection procedures, and analytical techniques. Methodological information must be presented in one coherent paragraph, without unnecessary theoretical explanations or separate methodological subsections, in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines. The research must demonstrate methodological rigor, transparency, and compliance with applicable ethical standards.
5. Results and Discussion: Research findings are presented systematically and supported by sufficient empirical, statistical, documentary, historical, textual, theoretical, or other academically appropriate evidence. The Results and Discussion must be integrated, with each substantive finding directly accompanied by its scholarly interpretation and critical discussion. The discussion must compare findings with relevant previous studies, explain theoretical or empirical relationships, identify original contributions, and discuss their implications for the relevant disciplinary field. Separate sections exclusively presenting results or discussion are not permitted.
6. Conclusions: The conclusions directly address the research objectives, accurately reflect the principal findings, and present a concise but substantive synthesis of the study's scholarly contributions. Conclusions must not merely repeat the abstract or discussion, introduce new findings, contain unsupported claims, or include in-text citations. Recommendations for future research or practical applications should be supported by the study's findings.
7. References: References must be relevant, accurate, academically credible, and consistent with the American Psychological Association (APA) Sixth Edition citation and referencing style. The journal recommends that approximately 80% of references consist of scholarly journal articles, conference proceedings, or published research findings, with an emphasis on relevant publications from the preceding five years. Foundational scholarly works and appropriate primary sources may also be considered when justified by the disciplinary context. All references must be appropriately cited in the manuscript, and all in-text citations must correspond accurately to the reference list.
8. Academic Writing and Manuscript Organization: The manuscript demonstrates clarity, coherence, logical organization, appropriate academic terminology, and compliance with the journal's formatting requirements. Arguments must be presented systematically, supported by credible evidence, and expressed in clear academic language. The manuscript must follow the journal's required structure and maintain consistency between its research objectives, methodology, findings, discussion, and conclusions.
Additional Evaluation Criteria Based on Manuscript Type
In addition to the general evaluation criteria, reviewers must consider the specific scholarly characteristics of each manuscript type.
a. Original Research Articles
Reviewers should evaluate the originality of the research problem, appropriateness of the theoretical framework, methodological rigor, credibility of research evidence, accuracy of data analysis, and significance of the findings.
The evaluation must consider whether the manuscript presents substantial empirical, theoretical, conceptual, or methodological contributions rather than merely describing research activities, institutional conditions, or previously established knowledge.
The research methods must be appropriate to the disciplinary context, including qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods, historical, comparative, phenomenological, ethnographic, experimental, or other academically recognized approaches.
b. Review Articles
Reviewers should evaluate the clarity of the review questions, appropriateness of the literature identification and selection procedures, methodological transparency, quality of critical analysis, and originality of the scholarly synthesis.
The evaluation must determine whether the manuscript identifies meaningful research gaps, inconsistencies, theoretical developments, or emerging scholarly perspectives.
Review Articles must demonstrate critical engagement with existing literature and contribute original interpretations or conceptual insights rather than merely summarizing previous publications.
c. Case Studies
Reviewers should evaluate the academic justification for case selection, clarity of the research context, methodological appropriateness, credibility of supporting evidence, analytical depth, and broader scholarly significance.
The evaluation must determine whether the case contributes meaningfully to theoretical understanding, empirical knowledge, disciplinary development, or practical applications within the humanities, social sciences, management, or related multidisciplinary fields.
Case Studies that merely describe institutions, organizational activities, cultural practices, historical events, or individual experiences without substantial scholarly analysis do not meet the journal's publication standards.
Case Studies are considered on a limited and selective basis, with particular emphasis on analytical originality, methodological rigor, and substantial scholarly contributions.
d. Literary Studies
Reviewers should evaluate the relevance of the selected textual materials, appropriateness of the theoretical and analytical frameworks, methodological transparency, interpretative rigor, and originality of the scholarly findings.
The evaluation must consider whether the manuscript provides meaningful contributions to literary scholarship, philosophical inquiry, religious studies, historical understanding, social science research, management scholarship, or interdisciplinary knowledge.
Literary Studies must demonstrate systematic textual analysis, credible interpretation, appropriate engagement with previous scholarship, and substantial theoretical or conceptual contributions.
Manuscripts that merely summarize literary works, reproduce textual materials, or describe cultural representations without critical scholarly analysis are not considered sufficient for publication.
Literary Studies are considered on a limited and selective basis, with particular emphasis on analytical originality, theoretical relevance, methodological rigor, and substantial scholarly contributions.
All manuscript types must be evaluated according to appropriate disciplinary and methodological standards. Reviewers must not impose research methods or theoretical approaches that are unsuitable for the manuscript's scholarly objectives.
3. Reviewer Responsibilities and Publication Ethics
Reviewers must maintain confidentiality, independence, fairness, objectivity, and professional integrity throughout the evaluation process.
Manuscripts must be treated as confidential scholarly documents and must not be disclosed, distributed, reproduced, or used for personal, professional, institutional, or commercial advantage without appropriate authorization.
Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest arising from professional relationships, institutional affiliations, research collaborations, financial interests, academic competition, or other circumstances that may compromise impartiality.
Reviewers who identify conflicts of interest must promptly inform the editorial team and decline assignments when an independent and objective evaluation cannot reasonably be ensured.
Reviews must be based exclusively on academic merit, methodological appropriateness, analytical quality, scholarly contribution, and compliance with publication ethics.
Reviewers must respect methodological diversity across the humanities, social sciences, and management and evaluate manuscripts according to the standards relevant to their respective disciplinary contexts.
Any suspected plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other research misconduct must be reported confidentially to the editorial team.
Reviewers must not recommend unnecessary citations to their own publications or those of colleagues, institutions, or particular journals for the purpose of increasing citation counts.
Reviewer comments must be constructive, respectful, specific, and supported by clear scholarly arguments. Personal criticism, discriminatory statements, and unsupported judgments are inappropriate.
Reviewers must identify substantive strengths, theoretical limitations, methodological weaknesses, analytical deficiencies, and opportunities for improving the manuscript's scholarly quality.
All reviewers must comply with the journal's Publication Ethics, Author Guidelines, and applicable peer-review policies.
4. Review Recommendations and Editorial Decisions
Following the evaluation, reviewers must provide clear, objective, and academically justified comments and recommend one of the following outcomes:
1. Accept Submission: The manuscript meets the journal's academic standards, demonstrates sufficient originality and scholarly contributions, complies with the Author Guidelines and publication ethics requirements, and requires no substantive revisions.
2. Minor Revisions: The manuscript demonstrates sufficient scholarly merit but requires limited corrections, clarifications, or improvements in academic writing, presentation, references, interpretation, or other aspects that do not substantially affect its research substance.
3. Major Revisions: The manuscript demonstrates potential scholarly merit but requires substantial improvements in its theoretical framework, research methodology, evidence, analytical interpretation, Results and Discussion, scholarly contributions, or overall presentation before it can be considered for publication.
4. Decline Submission: The manuscript contains significant academic, methodological, ethical, or substantive deficiencies that cannot reasonably be addressed through revision. Rejection may also be recommended when the manuscript falls outside the journal's Focus and Scope, lacks sufficient originality, or fails to demonstrate meaningful scholarly contributions.
For Case Studies and Literary Studies, reviewers must additionally consider whether the manuscript satisfies the journal's selective publication requirements, particularly analytical originality, methodological rigor, disciplinary relevance, and substantial scholarly significance.
Reviewer recommendations must be supported by specific academic arguments and relevant evidence.
Reviewers should distinguish between essential revisions required to improve scholarly validity and optional suggestions intended to enhance presentation or clarity.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final decision regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection rests exclusively with the editorial team of Metta: Jurnal Ilmu Multidisiplin.
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, and satisfactory completion of the peer-review and revision processes.
5. Review Timeline and Final Evaluation
Reviewers are expected to complete their evaluations within two weeks of accepting the review assignment.
Reviewers who anticipate delays, lack sufficient disciplinary expertise, or encounter circumstances that may compromise their ability to conduct an appropriate evaluation must promptly notify the editorial team.
Authors are required to address reviewers' comments and submit revised manuscripts within the deadline established by the editor.
Revised manuscripts must demonstrate that substantive reviewer recommendations have been appropriately addressed. Authors should provide clear explanations when particular recommendations cannot be adopted for valid academic or methodological reasons.
Revised manuscripts may undergo additional evaluation by the original reviewer or another qualified reviewer when necessary.
The editorial team reserves the right to request further revisions, seek additional expert evaluations, or reject manuscripts that fail to address significant academic, methodological, or ethical concerns.
Final acceptance is determined by the editorial team based on the manuscript's academic quality, originality, methodological rigor, scholarly contribution, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, compliance with publication ethics, and satisfactory completion of the review and revision processes.
Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, layout preparation, and publication in accordance with the journal's editorial policies.
Throughout the review process, Metta: Jurnal Ilmu Multidisiplin is committed to maintaining editorial independence, confidentiality, transparency, fairness, and academic integrity.
Through these guidelines, Metta: Jurnal Ilmu Multidisiplin seeks to maintain a credible, consistent, transparent, and academically rigorous peer-review process that supports the advancement of scholarly knowledge across the humanities, social sciences, management, and related multidisciplinary fields.
Feedback provided with commented directly on related articles (tab review> new comment on Microsoft Word).





